The Greatest American Dog Blows It – Big Time

Skip | July 22, 2008
Are the people at CBS who created Greatest American Dog off their medications – or on medication – or do they need medication?

How can you take a bulletproof concept like American Idol for DOGS and blow it so completely in such a short period of time without professional help?

I mean we’re talking about DOGS here. There are over 60,000,000 dog owners in the United States alone who would probably go without food before they would let their dogs go without a meal.

This is the country where people get death threats for abusing DOGS from the same people who couldn’t care less to what’s happening to people in Darfur.

A country where people will do anything for DOGS – except watch the Greatest American Dog more than once.

So tell me then, just how did the folks who came up with this reality show concept that should have been a no-brainer slam dunk (if you are a dog lover) lose touch with reality?

Instead of making up all kinds of stupid (and I mean stupid) pet tricks for the competition why not include real categories along with the fluff? People would so connect to, for example, a DOG who made it back from fighting in the war in Iraq, or one of the search dogs from 9//11, or a therapy DOG who eases people’s pain and suffering. And last, but not least are the mutts. Most DOGS are mutts as are most people. Need I say more?

All CBS had to do if they wanted to know what to look for in a Greatest American Dog contestant was watch Oprah and check out SkidBoot.

It’s really too bad, CBS had a chance to create something lasting and beneficial to television, society and DOGS, but they couldn’t hear the barking for the popping of champagne corks. I wonder if the execs at CBS will still be popping them at the end of this DOG. Don’t think so.


4 responses

I agree... CBS apparently did not have enough faith in

Brandon | July 23, 2008

I agree… CBS apparently did not have enough faith in dogs to realize that dogs, alone, are enough! No need to cast the Brandy and Beth Joy crazies of the world. There are thousands of remarkable dogs in America, that should have been represented by GAD. The only dogs on that show who embody the all-around characteristics of a “great American dog” are Preston, Star, and Tillman If you do your homework, you’ll find that Star actually saved his human mom’s life, by warning her owner Bill when his wife’s insulin levels were dangerously low. Tillman skateboards and snowboards… is named after a war hero… and, volunteers with his dad Ron at local schools. Last but certainly not least- the little dog and underdog, Preston.. the punk rock pomeranian. Yes, at first glance, he appears to be Paris Hilton’s dog’s metrosexual boyfriend… but Preston is the antithesis of his pocket-sized stereotype. Preston is bilingual, more than you can say for a lot of this country, incredibly bright… and has been volunteering with mom Laura Nativo at local hospitals, schools, etc for years- long before their debut on reality tv. Preston balances his therapy dog work with acting / modeling gigs… they live a refreshing lifestyle that would inspire most Hollywood humans. If Greatest American Dog had more dogs like Preston, Tillman and Star, it could have lived up to its potential. Hopefully the network execs will actually listen to their viewers for once, and make up for mis-casting in season 2. If not, I’m sure another network will copy their idea!

—-

Instead of making up all kinds of stupid (and I mean stupid) pet tricks for the competition why not include real categories along with the fluff? People would so connect to, for example, a DOG who made it back from fighting in the war in Iraq, or one of the search dogs from 9//11, or a therapy DOG who eases people’s pain and suffering.

Brandon, while you are telling others to "do some research,"

Julie Newman | July 24, 2008

Brandon, while you are telling others to “do some research,” perhaps you should do a little yourself. Your lack of knowledge about the other dogs and humans in the competition and their background is blaring. It’s fine to have your personal favorites, but it is also painfully obvious that you are here to do PR for the three dogs you mention, particularly Preston. Okay, we get it, you are a friend of Laura Nativo’s. That’s fine, but you lose credibility with your attempt to dismiss all the rest of the dogs. Probably your most telling statement is you referring to the dogs and humans as being “mis-cast.” Therein lies the problem and I dare say, you’ve just outed yourself. Unlike your friends, most of the people and dogs on the show are not in the entertainment industry. Like most Americans, most of the humans in the competition are not professional actors or movie producers looking to further their careers. Many of the dogs in the competition do not have agents and are merely beloved family pets who have never earned a dime for their owners - just like most American dogs. People aren’t watching because the show has been boring and the challenges silly.

Amazing. I'll reccommend my friends to visit you. How much

Dik | August 25, 2008

Amazing. I’ll reccommend my friends to visit you. How much time did you write a post?

Well, I am a Dog lover and I will be

Shannon | September 8, 2008

Well, I am a Dog lover and I will be trying out with my dog Jasmine, She is smarter than most people. She would make a great service dog. If I or my wife are carrying something and drop it, jasmine will pick it upa and bring it to us till our hands are clear to take it. Also, she can open a fridge and get a beer and then go back and close the door with only one command. She will stay in a car with the door wide open in a parking lot with hundreds of cars and people milling about, without the slightest thought of leaving or exploring. She knows her boundaries and is like talking to a person that listens and yearns to please. She also knows all the basic commands and alot more some have never seen. So, hopefully there will be another season and she’ll take first place.By the way, she’s a 4 yr old Black lab and Border Collie pond rescue!!

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment